Recently in the area of Dublin that I live in, many dog owners have been canvassing the local councils and trying to reverse the leash bye-laws which state that dogs MUST be on-leash in all areas of public parkland with the exception of the designated off-leash areas, or, dog parks. They advocate that dog parks are inappropriate places to bring dogs, and that dogs should be allowed to enjoy their walk around the whole park uninhibited by a leash. Their argument is that their dogs are happier and healthier having access to the entirety of the park versus the designated area.
The councils argue that many incidents have occurred with respect to off-lead dogs and other park users, and for the safety of all park users, it is best to keep dogs on-leash. As a compromise a dog-park (or designated off-leash area) is usually present in parks across Dublin.
Whilst I am also in favour of refraining from using dog parks, my position comes from the way that dog parks are currently used. A dog park isn't inherently bad in itself; it is just a label for a patch of land where dogs can be allowed off-lead. My issue arises from how these areas are currently used, and how their use can affect dogs and their behaviour on a more long-term basis.
As well as that, my experiences walking (with my rule-abiding leashed dogs) in the on-leash areas have been nothing short of miserable. This misery seems to be mine and mine alone. I dread seeing off-leash dogs in these areas; I've been accosted by many bouncing adolescent dogs and pushed, shoved, mugged, pulled at, chased, barked at, splashed at(!), followed and stalked on many occasions. My dogs have had to cope with unfamiliar dogs invading their space, sometimes intensely. All too often the owner is either nowhere to be seen or a long way off, on their phones or just onlooking. Sometimes the
owner, embarrassed by their dogs obnoxious behaviour will rush over only to be then engaged in a game of 'catch me if you can!' as their dog flees in anticipation of being put back on lead.I think there is a massive gap in knowledge about dog behaviour. We have transitioned from pet owning as a 'neighbourhood-dog' free-roaming culture to that of having our dogs as close family members who live inside and are treated almost like extra children. The rise of doggy daycares and the spread of misinformation about 'socialisation' has led to this desire for our dogs to be super-social friendly caricatures of themselves who can greet strange dogs and people as if they are already best friends. In reality this couldn't be further from their inherent canine nature.
I totally empathise with the above pet owners; I was that person once. I didn't know what I was doing or that my dogs needs were different to my interpretation of them. I also believed that my dog Lola (who was a freight train on lead when she saw other dogs) would be better served playing and meeting with other dogs, and truly believed my bouncy adolescent foxhound cross would calm right down with other dogs if she just. Played. With. More. Dogs. Walking her was fine, I believed, because I would just let her go say hi to all the dogs in the park. Many of the pet owners were there for the exact same thing, so we were all right, right?
In actual fact, Lola didn't calm down. Her behaviour on lead got worse with pulling me towards every dog we saw, so I would spot another off-lead dog, unclip the lead and let her 'get it out of her system' (translation: harass the other dog until she was tired enough/told off enough to come back). Each time she 'played' with another dog, it reinforced for her that other dogs are the source of all fun (regardless
Lola, circa 2008 |
of whether they liked it or not). I was not even a fleeting thought in her mind; she was all about the other dogs, which was rewarded over and over with each excursion. She was magnetised to other dogs and became frustrated on lead when she simply couldn't be let off. Her recall was non-existent and one had to simply wait for her to return because she wasn't going to leave the addiction of other dogs for me! Other dogs were like a beacon to her; her recall to other dogs was guaranteed, 100% perfect.
Who knows what nuisance we would have been if dog parks had been a bigger thing when Lola was in my life. I have visions of this hyper-friendly large white cumbersome dog pinning, sitting on and bouncing on other worried, shy or equally exuberant dogs, getting her jollies at the expense of other pets and their owners. She wasn't all bad; she was a sweet dog, and as she aged she became more dog-selective and less interested in greeting other dogs. I put that down to my hard work 'socialising' her. In reality a combination of her health issues, genetics and developmental stage probably had more to do with it. It definitely wasn't my input.
The thing is, you need to ask yourself what do you really want from your dog. Do you want them magnetised to other dogs like Lola, or would you prefer your dog to believe that YOU are the source of all the fun? Certainly I have chosen the latter since Lola. She taught me a lot, and the knowledge I've gained since then has shown me that walks can be pleasant, relaxing and full of joy when you teach your dog that you make fun happen.
Dog parks are still places I visit. When they're empty. An empty dog park is like finding a crock of gold, and lets me safely unclip the lead and allow my dog to.... run back to me. Sniffing, playing fetch, practicing appropriate skills on walks are things I now spend more time doing. I continue to reward my dogs when they look away from other dogs, and try and teach them that other dogs aren't the be all and end all; I am. This helps me with loose lead walking, recall, appropriate greetings and interactions when they DO get to meet dogs (and they do! appropriately...). A well-socialised dog can ignore other dogs and people 99% of the time.
And for off-leash experiences in on-leash parks?? Get a long-line.
For Ireland-based readers, the WonderPaws off leash dog park in Enniskerry, Co. Wicklow is a great off-lead park, totally fenced in and can be booked for private hire if you need a safe space for a good run.